Choosing an e-signature tool, step by step.
Reading reviews and feature tables only gets you so far. The reliable way to choose an e-signature tool is to try it on your own work with the people who will use it. This article sets out a short, practical process a team can follow over a couple of weeks, ending in a decision you can explain.
Step 1: Name an owner and a deadline
Choose one person to run the decision, even in a small business. Give them a date by which a choice will be made. Without an owner, tool selection drifts for months while everyone keeps printing.
Step 2: Map your documents
Make a short table of the documents you send for signature. For each, note who prepares it, who signs it, whether anyone must approve it first, whether it needs initials on every page, how long it is, and roughly how many go out each month. Mark any document that might need extra formality, and check those with your adviser.
In Canada, federal and provincial electronic commerce laws generally give electronic signatures the same effect as handwritten ones for most business documents. The documents that are excluded vary by province, and often include wills, powers of attorney and some land transfers. Check with your adviser which of your documents can be signed electronically.
Step 3: Talk to the people who sign
The people signing your documents are customers, staff and suppliers, and they never see the tool's dashboard. Ask a few of them how they would prefer to sign. You may learn that most of your customers open email on their phones, or that one supplier's office needs documents to arrive at a shared mailbox. That shapes what you test.
Step 4: Make a short list
Pick two or three tools that look like a fit. If you need a framework for comparing them, the criteria in how to judge e-signature software cover the signer experience, the sender's workflow, the record, security, integrations and how usage is counted. Check each provider's current plans directly.
Step 5: Run a pilot with real paperwork
Take three documents from your map, ideally a simple one, a long one with several signers, and one that needs an approval. Send each through every tool on your short list. Use colleagues or friendly customers as signers, and ask them to sign on the devices they normally use.
During the pilot, keep notes on:
- How long it took to prepare each envelope the first time, and again the second time.
- Whether signers had any trouble, and on what device.
- What the finished document looks like, and what record comes with it.
- How easy it was to find a completed document a week later.
- Whether anything needed a workaround.
Step 6: Check the edges
A pilot tends to cover the happy path. Deliberately try the awkward cases: a signer who declines, a document that changes after sending, a person who must be added late, a reminder going out, and a document someone needs to sign while standing next to you. These are where tools differ most in practice.
Step 7: Decide and write it down
Make the decision against your notes, not against the longest feature list. Write a short record: which tool, why, which documents it will handle, which documents stay on paper, and who owns the setup. That record helps the next person who joins, and it gives you something to review in a year.
Step 8: Roll out in a sensible order
Start with one document type and one team. Save it as a template, set reminders, and get it running well. Then add the next document. Turn on two-factor authentication and set roles for team members before many people are sending.
If SignAndGo is on your list
SignAndGo is quick to pilot because signers need no account and sign in a browser on any device. You can test signing order, approvals, reminders, templates, bulk sending, in-person and witness signing, acknowledgement-only envelopes, and the audit certificate and verification ID on each finished PDF. To see the flow, read how it works, or email privacy@myandgo.ai with questions about your pilot.
Frequently asked questions
- How long should an e-signature pilot run?
- A couple of weeks is usually enough to send real documents through each tool, including the awkward cases.
- Who should be involved in choosing a tool?
- An owner to run the decision, the people who send documents, and a few of the people who sign them.
- What should stay on paper?
- Anything your adviser says needs extra formality, which often includes wills, powers of attorney and some land transfers.
See SignAndGo for your team
Send your first envelope in a few minutes, and keep every signed copy with its audit trail.
See how it works