Digital signatures and electronic signatures are not the same thing.
People use the two terms interchangeably, and vendors do not always help. The difference is worth understanding, because it decides which questions you should ask when someone tells you a document needs a particular kind of signature.
Electronic signature is the umbrella term
An electronic signature is any electronic means of showing that a person agrees to a document: a drawn or typed signature, a checkbox, a click on a button marked I agree. It is a legal and practical idea, defined by intention rather than by technology.
A digital signature is narrower. It usually refers to a cryptographic technique applied to a file. So every digital signature is a kind of electronic signature, but most electronic signatures are not digital signatures in that technical sense.
What the cryptographic version involves
In the technical meaning, a digital signature relies on a pair of keys. A private key, held by the signer, is used to produce a value tied to the exact contents of the file. Anyone with the matching public key can check that value. If the file changes by even one character, the check fails.
To link the key to a real person or organization, the public key is usually wrapped in a certificate issued by a certificate authority, which has done some checking of identity before issuing it. Managing those certificates, keeping private keys safe and renewing them when they expire is the part that makes this approach heavier to run.
Two different questions
It helps to think of the two terms as answers to different questions.
- Did this person agree to this document? That is the question an electronic signature and its evidence answer: who was sent the document, how they opened it, when they signed and what they signed.
- Has this file changed since it was sealed? That is the question the cryptographic technique answers well, because any alteration breaks the check.
A practical signing service addresses both, in its own way. The first is covered by the record of the signing process. The second is covered by producing a finished document at the end and giving people a way to check it against the original record.
How SignAndGo approaches it
SignAndGo collects electronic signatures. Each signer receives a unique link by email, signs in a web browser, and every view and signature is written to the audit trail with the person's name, email address, the time and the IP address. When the envelope is complete, the audit certificate is appended to the signed PDF.
Every signed document also carries a verification ID. Anyone holding a copy can enter it on the public verify page to look up the record for that envelope. That gives a counterparty, an auditor or your own bookkeeper a simple way to confirm the document came from a real signing process, without needing special software or certificates of their own.
Which one do you need?
For most everyday business documents in Canada, an electronic signature backed by a good record is what people use. In Canada, federal and provincial electronic commerce laws generally give electronic signatures the same effect as handwritten ones for most business documents. The documents that are excluded vary by province, and often include wills, powers of attorney and some land transfers. Check with your adviser which of your documents can be signed electronically.
Some situations call for more. A regulator, a government portal, a lender or a particular contract may specify a certificate-based signature or another method. When a document names a specific requirement, follow it, and ask the party who set the requirement what they will accept.
Questions worth asking
When someone insists on a digital signature, these questions usually clarify what they actually need:
- Is this a rule set by law, by a regulator, or by the other party's own policy?
- Do they need proof of who signed, proof that the file has not changed, or both?
- Will they accept a signed PDF with an audit certificate and a verification ID?
- Is there a specific format or system they must receive the document in?
Often the answer is that a well-documented electronic signature is fine. Where it is not, you will know exactly why. For more on the record itself, read audit trails explained.
Frequently asked questions
- Is a digital signature more legally valid than an electronic one?
- Not as a general rule. For most business documents, electronic signatures with good evidence are widely used. Some situations specify a particular method, so check with your adviser and the party setting the requirement.
- Does SignAndGo issue certificate-based digital signatures?
- SignAndGo collects electronic signatures with an audit trail, an audit certificate on the signed PDF and a verification ID anyone can check on the public verify page.
- How can someone check a signed document later?
- They can enter the verification ID printed on the document at the public verify page to look up the record for that envelope.
See SignAndGo for your team
Send your first envelope in a few minutes, and keep every signed copy with its audit trail.
See how it works